Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Nathan Ormond's avatar

I think that if you know biographical details about Turing, that he certainly did think he was on the route to engineering life and conquering death. His initial forrays on this route were into computation, and this was at least in part motivated by the death ofChristopher Morcom who he developed a deep romantic love for. As such, it is not unreasonable to interpret him as exploring the topic of consciousness (which I suspect he would reject as conceptually confused).

Expand full comment
Kenny Easwaran's avatar

FWIW, I don't think Turing actually proposes the low-bar test as the test - the paragraph you quote is in a passage where he's speculating about the possibility of computers improving, and just lists this as a bar that he thinks they will reach by the year 2000. (They were a few years late, but he was surprisingly on-target with the hardware predictions, despite working before transistors and magnetic memory were even part of the architecture!)

I read the passage on the "strawberries and cream" objection as proposing a very high-bar test - probably higher even than a one-hour interaction.

Expand full comment
20 more comments...

No posts